Dos버전과 Window버전(w5.3) 해석결과 차이
2006-03-23
안녕하세요.
동일한 Input Data file을 Dos버전과 Window버전(w5.3)으로 각각 돌렸을 때
Moment, shear 등의 결과값이 Window버전에서 2배정도 크게 나타났습니다.
데이타파일은 첨부와 같고요.
결과값 차이가 너무 커서 문의드리니, 빠른 답변 부탁드립니다.
PROJECT Ventilation Shaft #4(right)
SOIL 1 매립층
4.431 1.7 0.8 1.0 30 1700 -1
2 충적층
5.678 1.8 0.9 3.0 24 1000 -1
3 풍화토
12.152 1.9 1.0 3.0 32 5500 -1
4 풍화암
16.010 2.1 1.2 4.0 34 6700 -1
5 연 암
17.138 2.4 1.5 20.0 35 50000 -1
6 보통,경암
70.000 2.5 1.6 25.0 38 200000
VWALL 1 41.195 0.013480 0.000215 21000000 1.500
STRUT 1 0.900 0.02355 20.254 2.000 0.0
2 3.798 0.01348 20.254 2.000 5.0
3 5.998 0.01348 20.254 2.000 5.0
4 8.198 0.01348 20.254 2.000 5.0
5 10.398 0.01348 20.254 2.000 5.0
6 12.598 0.01348 20.254 2.000 5.0
7 14.598 0.01348 20.254 2.000 5.0
8 16.598 0.01348 20.254 2.000 5.0
9 22.598 0.01348 20.254 2.000 5.0
10 28.598 0.01348 20.254 2.000 5.0
ANCHOR 1 18.098 0.0012848 0.00 0.10 1.500 0.00
2 19.598 0.0012848 0.00 0.10 1.500 0.00
3 21.098 0.0012848 0.00 0.10 1.500 0.00
4 24.098 0.0012848 0.00 0.10 1.500 0.00
5 25.598 0.0012848 0.00 0.10 1.500 0.00
6 27.098 0.0012848 0.00 0.10 1.500 0.00
7 30.098 0.0012848 0.00 0.10 1.500 0.00
8 31.598 0.0012848 0.00 0.10 1.500 0.00
9 33.098 0.0012848 0.00 0.10 1.500 0.00
10 34.598 0.0012848 0.00 0.10 1.500 0.00
11 36.098 0.0012848 0.00 0.10 1.500 0.00
12 37.598 0.0012848 0.00 0.10 1.500 0.00
DIVISION 0.2
STEP 1 굴 착 1.400 m
ITERATION 20 0.1
EARTH PRESSURE 0.000 0.648 1.000 0.648 1.000 0.648 1.400 0.648
WATER PRESSURE 1.000 0.000 1.400 0.400 1.400 0.000
EXCAVATION 1.400
STEP 2 주형보 설치
CONSTRUCTION STRUT 1
STEP 3 굴 착 4.298 m
EARTH PRESSURE 0.000 1.203 1.298 1.203 1.298 1.203 4.298 1.203
WATER PRESSURE 1.298 0.000 4.298 3.000 4.298 0.000
EXCAVATION 4.298
STEP 4 버팀보 2 설치
CONSTRUCTION STRUT 2
STEP 5 굴 착 6.498 m
EARTH PRESSURE 0.000 2.067 3.498 2.067 3.498 2.067 4.431 2.067
4.431 2.630 5.678 2.630 5.678 1.942 6.498 1.942
WATER PRESSURE 3.498 0.000 6.498 3.000 6.498 0.000
EXCAVATION 6.498
STEP 6 버팀보 3 설치
CONSTRUCTION STRUT 3
STEP 7 굴 착 8.698 m
EARTH PRESSURE 0.000 2.963 4.431 2.963 4.431 3.772 5.678 3.772
5.678 2.784 5.698 2.784 5.698 2.784 8.698 2.784
WATER PRESSURE 5.698 0.000 8.698 3.000 8.698 0.000
EXCAVATION 8.698
STEP 8 버팀보 4 설치
CONSTRUCTION STRUT 4
STEP 9 굴 착 10.898 m
EARTH PRESSURE 0.000 3.860 4.431 3.860 4.431 4.913 5.678 4.913
5.678 3.626 7.898 3.626 7.898 3.626 10.898 3.626
WATER PRESSURE 7.898 0.000 10.898 3.000 10.898 0.000
EXCAVATION 10.898
STEP 10 버팀보 5 설치
CONSTRUCTION STRUT 5
STEP 11 굴 착 13.098 m
EARTH PRESSURE 0.000 4.980 4.431 4.980 4.431 6.338 5.678 6.338
5.678 4.678 10.098 4.678 10.098 4.678 12.152 4.678 12.152 4.225 13.098 4.225
WATER PRESSURE 10.098 0.000 12.152 2.054 12.152 0.000
EXCAVATION 13.098
STEP 12 버팀보 6 설치
CONSTRUCTION STRUT 6
STEP 13 굴 착 15.098 m
EARTH PRESSURE 0.000 6.267 4.431 6.267 4.431 7.976 5.678 7.976
5.678 5.887 12.098 5.887 12.098 5.887 12.152 5.887 12.152 5.317 15.098 5.317
WATER PRESSURE 12.098 0.000 12.152 0.054 12.152 0.000
EXCAVATION 15.098
STEP 14 버팀보 7 설치
CONSTRUCTION STRUT 7
STEP 15 굴 착 17.098 m
EARTH PRESSURE 0.000 6.688 4.431 6.688 4.431 8.512 5.678 8.512
5.678 6.283 12.152 6.283 12.152 5.675 16.010 5.675 16.010 0.000 17.098 0.000
EXCAVATION 17.098
STEP 16 버팀보 8 설치
CONSTRUCTION STRUT 8
STEP 17 굴 착 18.598 m
EARTH PRESSURE 0.000 6.688 4.431 6.688 4.431 8.512 5.678 8.512 5.678 6.283
12.152 6.283 12.152 5.675 16.010 5.675 16.010 0.000 17.138 0.000 17.138 0.000 18.598 0.000
EXCAVATION 18.598
STEP 18 앵 커 1 설치
CONSTRUCTION ANCHOR 1
STEP 19 굴 착 20.098 m
EARTH PRESSURE 0.000 6.688 4.431 6.688 4.431 8.512 5.678 8.512 5.678 6.283
12.152 6.283 12.152 5.675 16.010 5.675 16.010 0.000 17.138 0.000 17.138 0.000 20.098 0.000
EXCAVATION 20.098
STEP 20 앵 커 2 설치
CONSTRUCTION ANCHOR 2
STEP 21 굴 착 21.598 m
EARTH PRESSURE 0.000 6.688 4.431 6.688 4.431 8.512 5.678 8.512 5.678 6.283
12.152 6.283 12.152 5.675 16.010 5.675 16.010 0.000 17.138 0.000 17.138 0.000 21.598 0.000
EXCAVATION 21.598
STEP 22 앵 커 3 설치
CONSTRUCTION ANCHOR 3
STEP 23 굴 착 23.098 m
EARTH PRESSURE 0.000 6.688 4.431 6.688 4.431 8.512 5.678 8.512 5.678 6.283
12.152 6.283 12.152 5.675 16.010 5.675 16.010 0.000 17.138 0.000 17.138 0.000 23.098 0.000
EXCAVATION 23.098
STEP 24 버팀보 9 설치
CONSTRUCTION STRUT 9
STEP 25 굴 착 24.598 m
EARTH PRESSURE 0.000 6.688 4.431 6.688 4.431 8.512 5.678 8.512 5.678 6.283
12.152 6.283 12.152 5.675 16.010 5.675 16.010 0.000 17.138 0.000 17.138 0.000 24.598 0.000
EXCAVATION 24.598
STEP 26 앵 커 4 설치
CONSTRUCTION ANCHOR 4
STEP 27 굴 착 26.098 m
EARTH PRESSURE 0.000 6.688 4.431 6.688 4.431 8.512 5.678 8.512 5.678 6.283
12.152 6.283 12.152 5.675 16.010 5.675 16.010 0.000 17.138 0.000 17.138 0.000 26.098 0.000
EXCAVATION 26.098
STEP 28 앵 커 5 설치
CONSTRUCTION ANCHOR 5
STEP 29 굴 착 27.598 m
EARTH PRESSURE 0.000 6.688 4.431 6.688 4.431 8.512 5.678 8.512 5.678 6.283
12.152 6.283 12.152 5.675 16.010 5.675 16.010 0.000 17.138 0.000 17.138 0.000 27.598 0.000
EXCAVATION 27.598
STEP 30 앵 커 6 설치
CONSTRUCTION ANCHOR 6
STEP 31 굴 착 29.098 m
EARTH PRESSURE 0.000 6.688 4.431 6.688 4.431 8.512 5.678 8.512 5.678 6.283
12.152 6.283 12.152 5.675 16.010 5.675 16.010 0.000 17.138 0.000 17.138 0.000 29.098 0.000
EXCAVATION 29.098
STEP 32 버팀보 10 설치
CONSTRUCTION STRUT 10
STEP 33 굴 착 30.598 m
EARTH PRESSURE 0.000 6.688 4.431 6.688 4.431 8.512 5.678 8.512 5.678 6.283
12.152 6.283 12.152 5.675 16.010 5.675 16.010 0.000 17.138 0.000 17.138 0.000 30.598 0.000
EXCAVATION 30.598
STEP 34 앵 커 7 설치
CONSTRUCTION ANCHOR 7
STEP 35 굴 착 32.098 m
EARTH PRESSURE 0.000 6.688 4.431 6.688 4.431 8.512 5.678 8.512 5.678 6.283
12.152 6.283 12.152 5.675 16.010 5.675 16.010 0.000 17.138 0.000 17.138 0.000 32.098 0.000
EXCAVATION 32.098
STEP 36 앵 커 8 설치
CONSTRUCTION ANCHOR 8
STEP 37 굴 착 33.598 m
EARTH PRESSURE 0.000 6.688 4.431 6.688 4.431 8.512 5.678 8.512 5.678 6.283
12.152 6.283 12.152 5.675 16.010 5.675 16.010 0.000 17.138 0.000 17.138 0.000 33.598 0.000
EXCAVATION 33.598
STEP 38 앵 커 9 설치
CONSTRUCTION ANCHOR 9
STEP 39 굴 착 35.098 m
EARTH PRESSURE 0.000 6.688 4.431 6.688 4.431 8.512 5.678 8.512 5.678 6.283
12.152 6.283 12.152 5.675 16.010 5.675 16.010 0.000 17.138 0.000 17.138 0.000 35.098 0.000
EXCAVATION 35.098
STEP 40 앵 커 10 설치
CONSTRUCTION ANCHOR 10
STEP 41 굴 착 36.598 m
EARTH PRESSURE 0.000 6.688 4.431 6.688 4.431 8.512 5.678 8.512 5.678 6.283
12.152 6.283 12.152 5.675 16.010 5.675 16.010 0.000 17.138 0.000 17.138 0.000 36.598 0.000
EXCAVATION 36.598
STEP 42 앵 커 11 설치
CONSTRUCTION ANCHOR 11
STEP 43 굴 착 38.098 m
EARTH PRESSURE 0.000 6.688 4.431 6.688 4.431 8.512 5.678 8.512 5.678 6.283
12.152 6.283 12.152 5.675 16.010 5.675 16.010 0.000 17.138 0.000 17.138 0.000 38.098 0.000
EXCAVATION 38.098
STEP 44 앵 커 12 설치
CONSTRUCTION ANCHOR 12
STEP 45 굴 착 39.695 m
EARTH PRESSURE 0.000 6.688 4.431 6.688 4.431 8.512 5.678 8.512 5.678 6.283
12.152 6.283 12.152 5.675 16.010 5.675 16.010 0.000 17.138 0.000 17.138 0.000 39.695 0.000
EXCAVATION 39.695
INSERTION CHECK
GROUND SETTLEMENT
END